Quick Thought – The I Have Nothing To Hide Brigade

It never actually fails, every time there’s an article or mention of new surveillance tools being used by law enforcement or some other security group, complaints about the privacy violation are met with the “I have nothing to hide” opposition.

The inference here, of course, is that anyone desiring privacy has something to hide, and should be silenced, which is dumb.

Actually, I think the “I have nothing to hide” brigade is full of naive fools. The reason I think that, is because the idea that the government, or security groups can go right ahead and capture all the information they want,  since I haven’t done anything wrong, is dependent on all of that information about us never being lost or misused.

Sure, that never happens.

No one with access to that much information has ever misused it to stalk people. (Not)

No one who shouldn’t have access to that information has ever hacked in and made it available. (Not)

No one has ever kept data for years that they weren’t supposed to. (Not)

No one has ever had a health condition revealed to their employers or others due to misuse of private information (Not)

The truth is, if there is a place where that much information can be gathered about any individual, eventually someone is going to misuse it, and eventually someone is also going to alter it to their own benefit.

If someone alters your location data to make it look like you were at the scene of a crime, who’s going to believe you weren’t?

So, again, I ask. Even if you think you have nothing to hide, there’s a risk to anyone having and controlling that much data about us. Why shouldn’t we question collecting it in the first place?

Similar Posts

  • |

    Why did they do that?

    Something that I thought about today when I was talking to someone on the Friends in Tech forums. Their question was about being unable to see the Temporary Internet Files folder even after showing hidden folders. I’ve found that when I installed IE7, that, and the history folder are “protected operating system file and folders”,…

  • Windows Home Server

    As usual when it comes to new Microsoft technology, Paul Thurott has the definitive review of Windows Home Server. Yeah, it just makes me want it more. I especially dig the idea of having my photos be accessible remotely, easy backups, and having a center to my network without having to pay for a full…

  • Linked – With Increased Cybersecurity Awareness, Why Does Phishing Still Work?

    You have to create a culture where everyone is expected to verify information before acting, even when it’s coming from the CEO or Managing Partner.

    What are you doing to create an environment where your people feel free to take the time necessary to evaluate the difference between a scam and legitimate communication and the ability to question authority in order to get more information?

  • Firefox Hole

    By now I’m sure you’ve all heard about the security hole in Firefox, and the “recommended fixes”. Here’s the thing though, turning off Javascript disables all those cool little Greasemonkey scripts, and turning off “Let website install software” just makes it more difficult for people to get extensions for Firefox. It’s those extensions and add-ons…

  • |

    WordPress iPhone App

    Writing this from my iPhone using the WordPress app. I like the ability to write quick posts fe anywhere, but like email on my phone, anything that will require a lot of typing will have to wait until I’m at a keyboard! On the other hand, this is a great way to handle comments, I…

  • Gadget Heads

    Here’s an interesting theory from Daniel Taylor (Spotted via Adam Gaffin): I think of it like hot dogs. Nobody wants to know what goes inside a hot dog. And once you do, it’s kind of hard to get excited about eating one. That’s the way it is with mobile devices. There are gadget heads in…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Your post must include a link to this post.

How does this work?
Write a response on your own website and include a link to this post. Then submit your response’s URL here. Your response may appear here after moderation. To update or remove it, edit or delete your original post and submit the same URL again. Learn more about Webmentions.