Google Autolink

By the way, like I said before, I wasn’t going to say anything about the controversy about Autolink until I had actually seen it working myself. I have now, and while I’m not in love with it, I just can’t seem to get all that worked up about it. Here’s why:

– It only changes the tracking number, address, ISBN number into a link when the user goes to the toolbar and tells it to. It doesn’t “change the display of my page”, when the page opens it looks exactly like it does to people not using the Autolink, until they hit a button on the toolbar. The “uninformed user” who might be confused and think you linked to something you did not, would have to be pretty brain dead to open a page, see it display the way you designed it, ask the toolbar to create an autolink and then somehow think that new link the toolbar just added, is actually a link you created. Since showing Autolinks requires end-user interaction and understanding, doesn’t that preclude the “uninformed user” from seeing those links in the first place?

– If the address, tracking number, ISBN, etc. is already a link, Google won’t even show it as an Autolink option, let alone “overwrite my links”.

Is the potential there for Google to misuse this, by creating ads based on keywords, automatically creating the link upon page load, or overriding existing links? Yes. Does that worry me to some extent? Yes. But I’m not going to spend a lot of time ranting about it until, you know, they actually do misuse it.

Similar Posts

  • Feed Readers

    Remember back last year when I did a comparison of all the available RSS aggregators at that time. Do you have any idea how many I would have to download and use to do that now? Talk about an exploding market of choices! Well, if you want a somewhat rough idea of some of the…

  • This could be huge!

    This morning over at Pirillo’s blog I saw that beta version 2.0 of the Google Toolbar is out. I’ve been a big fan of the toolbar since I first ran across it, and this version adds a popup blocker, an autofill and a “BlogThis” feature! Sounds very cool, and the popup blocker eliminates one of…

  • Upgrade update

    My original prediction, of course, was a month and 4 meetings. The President got the memo yesterday, had a short meeting with my boss, and sent me 4 different emails with questions and suggestions for possible changes. My boss is now trying to schedule a meeting for us to discuss options with 3-4 other people,…

  • |

    If They Sell Advertising We Aren’t Their Customers

    I found much of what Doc Searls wrote about Mozilla to be true of just about all of the services we use online these days. By becoming an advertising company (in addition to everything else it is), Mozilla now experiences a problem that has plagued ad-supported media for the duration: its customers and consumers are…

  • It’s official!

    I am officially a stud, according to Google: Search for “do that to me one more time i can never get enough of a man like you” Someone actually searched for that, and actually came here. I can only imagine the disappointment they must have felt. They probably looked like those Canadian pairs skaters. *L*…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

To respond on your own website, enter the URL of your response which should contain a link to this post's permalink URL. Your response will then appear (possibly after moderation) on this page. Want to update or remove your response? Update or delete your post and re-enter your post's URL again. (Find out more about Webmentions.)