You Belong sign with multi-colored background.

Linked – Culture Fit – Another Way to Discriminate?

ByMike McBride Reading Time: 2 minutes

Ahh the old “Culture fit” when it comes to hiring. It’s complicated. We do want to hire people who will work well in the current team, and not disrupt things negatively, but we have to come to grips with this too:

“At best, we pick out those indicators that align with those we already believe are important. When we say a candidate is not a fit, it is often a thinly disguised code for not hiring someone who does not fit our bias.”

In my experience, cultural fit is a double-edged sword. It can be used to find someone who will slide right into our team comfortably. It can also be used as an excuse to only hire a certain type of person.

For example, if your sales team is a bunch of “bros”, hiring more will keep them running without any HR issues, but should you? Would having a diverse sales team actually be the better choice for your business and society as a whole? Similarly, if your culture revolves around families, and people talking every Monday morning about their kids, a good cultural fit is going to be a parent. That’s not all that diverse.

On the other hand, if your culture stresses wellness and work-life balance, hiring someone who strolls into an interview talking about how no one who works less than 80 hours a week is important might not be a great culture fit, right?

There’s no simple answer here but I would look at how you define culture. There should be an organizational culture that includes diversity. Think more about “we value a variety of experiences and viewpoints” as opposed to “we like to work in a locker room environment” and then find the diverse group of people who “fit” your culture.

I will agree with Kevin on this though, “culture fit” is too frequently just code for people like me, and that needs to go away.

https://fotnews.futureoftalent.org/p/culture-fit-another-way-to-discriminate

Similar Posts

  • |

    Linked: Three-quarters of employees’ careers impacted by mental health, report finds

    ByMike McBride Reading Time: 2 minutes

    I think a little anxiety and anger are appropriate now. Being distracted from your work should actually be a pretty normal reaction to what is going on in the world. Just replace your own national politics for the UK in that survey and can you really say that something hasn’t prevented you from being your best at work during the last couple of years? I’m in the US, I think it’s crazy that there are people going about their work as if nothing is happening, but I also know that is the corporate culture for many of us as well. For the hours you are “at” work, that’s our time. Spend your own time worrying about the world, grieving for lost loved ones, caring for your family, or your own needs, etc.

    This is wrong on so many levels. Your people are not hours of labor on a spreadsheet, they are human beings, and human beings should absolutely be affected by what is going on in the world. Expecting them not to be during work hours tells me a lot more about the management team than it does about the workforce.

    It surely doesn’t say anything good about the management team either.

  • |

    Linked – Junior tech workers can’t find jobs. Are coding boot camps in trouble?

    ByMike McBride Reading Time: 2 minutes

    The job market for people who can write code has fallen apart. Partly because of AI and partly because companies over-invested in engineers and tools that never could be as successful as they thought. (Remember when we were all going to be hanging out in the metaverse?) Of course, the people running these companies weren’t held accountable for those choices, but I’m past hoping that will ever happen. 

    So, now the mantra will be “learn AI,” at least until that market isn’t everything companies are currently promising and we go through this whole thing again. 

    It’s best not to get comfortable with anything in the current tech marketplace. The skills in high demand today won’t be those in high demand five years from now. If you’re entering college and embarking on a technology major, the tech will be changed by the time you graduate. 

  • |

    Study Shows Most of Us Think We’re Right, and Others Will See That

    ByMike McBride Reading Time: 2 minutes

    Well, that’s what we tell ourselves anyway, and if you pay attention to social media at all, you’ll surely not be shocked by this: New research shows that most people tend to believe that others will come around to their point of view over time. This belief in a “favorable future” sheds light on some…

  • The Mental Health Impacts of Being New to the Workplace

    ByMike McBride Reading Time: 2 minutes

    There should be no question about how to access resources. There should be an expectation that there are people you can reach out to who would help you navigate those resources and that managers are supportive of basic mental health activities that help avoid burnout.

    Anything less just isn’t good enough.

  • Worth Reading – The main reason your company’s healthcare costs are skyrocketing

    ByMike McBride Reading Time: 2 minutes

    Here’s the interesting thing. When workplaces have made people ill, we’ve done little to hold them accountable. We have done some things, though. (Asbestos lawsuits, for example.) It hasn’t amounted to much in the broader context, but we do acknowledge that working in an environment that causes health issues is generally frowned upon. We have not reached that point with mental health. We’ve not started thinking about the poor health outcomes for people pushed to the brink and beyond by their managers.

    We should, and businesses should be leading the charge, because this is costing them a ton in health insurance premiums.

  • |

    Linked: Women in cybersecurity need more than inspiration

    ByMike McBride Reading Time: 4 minutes

    What Sherri talks about in regards to the security industry is something I’m seeing over and over again when reading about diversity. The child care question.

    Let me share another resource on the topic with you. In December, there was an episode of People I Mostly Admire with Claudia Goldin, where she talked about the concept of “Greedy work”.

    The topic she was chatting about was the gender pay gap and how much child care contributes to it, and one of the reasons we have a gender pay cap, aside from the percentage that is actually discrimination, is that greedy work doesn’t account for child care, but it pays more. So in many families, they have to make a choice between less pay and the flexibility to equally share the child care. The economics of that don’t usually make sense, so one parent takes on the greedy work to maximize the family income while the other steps back to a more flexible role in order to provide the majority of child care. With social norms being what they are, and the other issues that contribute to a gender pay gap, that most often means the man in a heterosexual couple, and here we are with women being vastly underrepresented in these types of positions.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

To respond on your own website, enter the URL of your response which should contain a link to this post's permalink URL. Your response will then appear (possibly after moderation) on this page. Want to update or remove your response? Update or delete your post and re-enter your post's URL again. (Find out more about Webmentions.)