Private Sign

Worth Reading – AI Note-Taking Apps Are Violating User Privacy

Honestly, the first time I saw an ad for Granola, I immediately thought, “This seems illegal and is going to get someone in a lot of trouble”:

Unlike most AI note-takers, which show up as bots that have to be visibly admitted into the video call, Granola is built around invisibility. According to the app’s own marketing copy, the app’s competitive advantage is it runs locally on a user’s device so that “other people in the room won’t know it’s there.” Lawyers fighting for the plaintiff say that this is the textbook definition of an illegal wiretap.

https://lifehacker.com/tech/ai-note-taking-apps-are-violating-user-privacy

Not every state requires both parties of a call to be aware of recording, but some do, and setting aside the legality, it’s just creepy and likely unethical for lawyers to be out there doing that with client calls.

And seriously, if you’re doing it with meetings with your employees, you’re gross.

At some point, someone in development at Granola should have considered how this was going to be used, and given the way they market it, maybe they did, and thought it sounded like a good business plan. Like many tech companies these days, privacy isn’t a thing.

Similar Posts

  • |

    Book Review – Your Witness

    I was contacted a while back by a publicist with Planned Television Arts offering me a free copy of Your Witness: Lessons on Cross-Examination and Life from Great Chicago Trial Lawyers. She explained that even though I am not a lawyer, they really thought the book would be appealing to anyone with an interest in…

  • What I’m Sharing (weekly)

    The Implications of Working Without an Office

    The Explosion of Organizational Data is at a Tipping Point: Here’s How to Understand What You Have and Mitigate Risk

    This Big Law Firm Has Permanent Plans for Remote Working

    Zooming from video meetings to discovery requests about video meetings

    How To Enable Ransomware Protection Feature on Windows 10

    Coronavirus: The Expert’s Practical Guide to Job Searching During Self Containment

    Discovery from Microsoft Office 365

    Deloitte Takes Aim at U.S. Legal Services Market With Tech Unit

    – Not really a surprise, the Big 4 have been moving significantly into this area, and thanks to COVID layoffs, lots of in-house teams are doing with less, looking for options.

    10 Tips for Job Searching When You Also Have Depression

    Estonia is Building a “Robot Judge” to Help Clear Legal Backlog

    – Interesting, but dangerous if they can’t get the bias out of the #AI

    Beware of the Perils of Allowing Self-Collection

  • |

    Linked: Law Firm Data Security Vulnerabilities

    These results from the 2018 ABA Legal Technology Survey are not at all good, given how much information is laying around law firms these days. “Less than half of the responding firms have the following policies or plans that are important facets of a law firm’s security posture:  computer acceptable use policy (41%); remote access…

  • | |

    Linked – AI Agents Come For White Collar Jobs

    How often have we watched a C-level person from Microsoft remind us that AI will not take our jobs but help us do our jobs better? It was there to assist us, not work for us.

    “It’s even in the name, Copilot.”

    When I heard them talk about agents being our team members and eventually managing other agents and their tasks, I immediately thought this was no longer a copilot. If it’s a team member, that means fewer human team members to do the work.

  • Weighing security and privacy after Sept. 11

    Weighing security and privacy after Sept. 11 These guys are pretty much saying what I’ve been saying. (Maybe I should be on a panel somewhere?) That all of these wonderful ideas to make us feel safer, would not, in fact, make us any safer. But it would make us all a lot less free. Lots…

One Comment

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Your post must include a link to this post.

How does this work?
Write a response on your own website and include a link to this post. Then submit your response’s URL here. Your response may appear here after moderation. To update or remove it, edit or delete your original post and submit the same URL again. Learn more about Webmentions.